Liverpool’s Greatest… Goalkeeper

The secret of any great team starts from the back. As Liverpool found out when mounting a title charge in the early 2000’s – you cannot hope to win the title if you have a problematic keeper. Your keeper should have the respect of the rest of the team in their ability.

In the first of our series, several of Anfield Online’s contributors have each come up with their own choice for Liverpool’s Greatest Ever Goalkeeper.

Shortlist: Bruce Grobbelaar | Elisha Scott | Ray Clemence | Pepe Reina

Bruce Grobbelaar

Bruce Grobbelaar - spaghetti legs against Roma

Bruce Grobbelaar - spaghetti legs against Roma

For me, the greatest goalkeeper in my memory has to be Bruce.

Whilst growing up, he could surely not have imagined that one day he would play for England’s most successful team and lift the European Cup. Whilst an outstanding sportsman in several different domains as a boy, Grobbelaar was ultimately to sign up for national service in the Rhodesian Army. In the heat of the live action that he was to endure for two years, football was surely the last thing on his mind.

The then second choice keeper for the Vancouver Whitecaps was sent on loan to Crewe Alexandra, where he was to make 24 appearances, during which he was scouted by the Reds, who he would sign for in 1980. He had some huge boots to fill, with the momentous task of replacing Ray Clemence. Bruce not only did that, but went on to become a legend in his own right.

As well as being a tremendous shot-stopper, with an athletic, almost gymnastic ability, Grobbelaar was probably most famous for his outlandish character, with his quirky wit making him a fans favourite. On the field, however, Bruce was often seen berating his defence if he felt they weren’t playing at their best, the kind of passion and determination to succeed that made him loved by the Kop.

Grobbelaar’s most famous footballing moment is obviously the penalty shoot-out in the 1984 European Cup final. Between chewing on the netting, and his comical, wobbly legged routine, his antics were enough to put off the Roma strikers and help the Reds lift their fourth European trophy in just 8 years. This moment perhaps summed up Grobbelaar, with his mental strength and self confidence at it’s highest.

With over 600 matches for the Reds to his name, and a medal cabinet full to bursting point, Grobbelaar is an obvious candidate for the greatest keeper to have played for Liverpool.

Elisha Scott

Elisha Scott

One of our earliest legends and our longest serving player which span over two decades. (21 years and 52 days to be exact) Over that time he played in a remarkable 467 games for the Reds keeping an impressive 137 clean sheets which, currently, is the third most for any Liverpool keeper. His goalkeeping also helped Liverpool to back-to-back titles in 1922 and 1923, though these were the only pieces of silverware Elisha picked up during his time at Liverpool. There may have been more had his career not be disrupted by World War I.

As well as domestic success, he received a few international call ups while at Anfield. He was called up to represent the then, Ireland, 31 times.

Elisha Scott – Liverpool’s greatest goalkeeper

Ray Clemence

Ray Clemence

There’s good goalkeepers and there’s great goalkeepers. But there’s very few who come close to Ray Clemence.

At just 18 years of age, Bill Shankly brought Clemence to Liverpool from Scunthorpe Utd in June 1967, but it was to be over a year until Clemence made his Liverpool debut. Having to ply his trade in the reserves, waiting to get in ahead of then, Liverpool’s first choice keeper, Tommy Lawrence, Clemence was given his chance in the League Cup against Swansea, September 1968. But it was soon a time of transformation for the reds and Clemence soon cemented his place as number one goalkeeper for the reds.

The 70’s were to be an important era in Liverpool’s history and it was Clemence who was to form the solid base for Liverpool to dominate at home and in Europe. Making his league debut away to Nottingham Forest in January 1970, it was from here where it all started for Clemence in the Liverpool goal.

Amazingly, Clemence only missed six league matches in the next eleven years. Picking up many league honours along the way and also being the first Liverpool goalkeeper to win the European Cup with the reds, these achievements paid testament to his abilities to keep the door firmly shut in the Liverpool defence. You only have to look at the 1978-79 season where Clemence only conceded just 16 goals.

The stats speak for themselves, but there was no denying Clemence was a huge presence at the back for the reds. Where other goalkeepers at the time would be shy of coming away from their line, Clemence wouldn’t hesitate to come out of his comfort zone and put pressure on the opposing strikers. A trend that is common these days. He was amazingly agile for a big man. He could jump, twist and turn in a flash and still pick the ball out of the air, away from an opposing player’s head, with extreme ease. Even with one hand sometimes. His reactions were instant and his awareness was as sharp as a razor.

There’s no surprise that when Liverpool were a force at home and in Europe in the 70‘s, Ray Clemence was a big part of the team. A true Liverpool great.

Pepe Reina

Pepe Reina

It’s still difficult to believe that Liverpool’s present keeper, and in my view our best ever, only cost us £6M when we purchased him in the summer of 2005.

After starting his youth career at Barcelona he spent time on loan at Villarreal before making the deal permanent after some excellent displays. It was from there that he was brought to Anfield.

His athleticism, strength and reactions have been there for all to see as Rafa began his revolution of turning the reds flaky defence in to the strongest in the country.

Soon after his arrival – Liverpool’s goalkeeping records started to change hands at rapid rates. By December he had kept 6 consecutive clean sheets in the Premier League – a new Liverpool record – and then went on to extend it to 8 games.

During this time he also broke Liverpool’s all time clean sheet record – going 11 games without being beaten.

Before his first season was out he reached 50 games. In doing so he set a club record for the fewest goals conceded in the first 50. His meagre 29 beating his closest rival – Ray Clemence’s 32.  At the end of his first season he was awarded the coveted Golden Glove award.

In the season finale of the FA Cup Final, Reina went on to save 3 of West Ham’s 4 spot kicks. Helping Liverpool to lift the FA Cup.

The next season he helped the reds to the Champions League final with two impressive performances in both semi-finals against Chelsea. Great saves in the games were only helped when he saved two of Chelsea’s three spot kicks in the second leg penalty shoot-out. At the end of his second season he again won the Golden Glove.

2008 saw a third consecutive golden glove, and he became the fastest Liverpool keeper to keep 50 clean sheets. Doing it in 92 games, three sooner than his closest rival. In 2009 he became the fastest keeper to reach 100 clean sheets – in his 197th game.

There is a lot to like about Pepe Reina.  His enthusiasm, drive and desire are all Liverpool mentalities.  Off the pitch he is said to be integral in helping new players settle in – and is one of the true characters of the dressing room.  He may not yet have the medal haul of some of his predecessors, thanks mainly to the 10 players in front of him, but his raw natural goalkeeping ability helped Liverpool translate from a poor defensive side in to a much stronger unit in the four years he has been at the club.

For me, Reina IS Liverpool’s Greatest ever goalkeeper.

What do you think? Who is right? Have we missed the real number 1? Who is your greatest Liverpool goalkeeper?

Vote here and leave your comments below.

[poll id="15"]

  • Ammadahad

    reina is good i hope he win the worldcup

  • Ammadahad

    pepe reine for life LIVERPOOL IS THE BEST!”

  • Tinchodudek

    DUDEK IS THE BEST,REINA SUCKS!!

  • Anonymous

    thank’s a lot to rafa co’z bring a greatest goalkeeper i’ve seen ever.only one spaniard 1st eleven to save the crazy ball

  • The King Is Back

    Luis Suarez will become LFC’s best ever keeper!

  • Maurizio

    RAY CLEMENCE FOREVER NUMBER ONE!FANTASTICK GOALKEEPPER!Di gran lunga il più forte portire della storia del Liverpool,insieme al grande Gordon Banks il più grande nella storia del calcio inglese.Ricordo a tutti che Ray Clemence è l’unico portiere inglese che è stato in grado di vincere 3 coppe dei campioni,e 3 coppe uefa.NESSUNO COME LUI! CLEM FOREVER NUMBER ONE!

  • Red Knight

    As per usual Elisha Scott’s details are incorrect..Plus anyone on here never saw him play a match..???he was Loyal to Liverpool FC ..nearly 22yrs !!! Just wondering, how many on here was watching him play from 1912-34 ??? ….Still holds the title as LFC’s Longest Goalkeeper !!!! Sadly departed though..Wonder will it ever be beaten ???? Don’t think so myself ;) YNWA Lish !!!

  • Bucko

    I have seen all these keepers (and more) for the Reds ,they are all great in thier own way, But Ray Clemence is by far the best , with Pepe Reina the best since CLEM.

  • baz

    in my time, i can only have Grobbelaar as my goalie… that guy is like spiderman and screams at his defence like he means business… its all good.. with hansen in defence, gerard holding ad comanding the midfield, and rushie’s killer goals… i have picked the right players, no doubt the greatest of all time :)

  • POOLEY

    WHAT ABOUT DUDEK 2005 FINAL

  • K-ad

    It has to be Clemence, not forgetting Tommy Lawrence who was at the start of the Shankly success with new defenders coming around that time.

  • Arvince

    Reina,liverpool choose the right keeper which is you..I believe that :

    If liverpool have a dream keeper,
    Give a chance to Reina…

    And now,Reina is the best keeper which stand with the team…

  • sajad

    reina is the best in the world.i hope he win the worldcup with spain.

  • marcus

    where’s Dudek??

  • sharon r

    reina all the way

  • jedi stealth

    if rafa can get a settled back four,reina will be without a shadow of doubt,no1.

  • xan

    the hole liverpool team is great im sure the will recover the 4 place and liverpool could not have a great goalkeeper like pepe reina.

  • Jack C

    Reina is the best and I mean THE BEST goalkeeper who has played for Liverpool

  • mark gibson

    pepe is the best followed by clemence even though ray was there longer reina was a snip and is worth more than torres lol

  • gerrardguyz

    i always choose pepe reina to best goalkeeper

  • Chloee

    Brucie all the wayy. Go Bruciee (:

  • TheSinj

    I’d echo the thoughts above – Clem for now but in ten years time depending on how things go for him and the club we could well be talking about Reina as the best of all time.

  • Bryan

    Hey, Pepe is NOT good at all. I would rather say the ex goalkeepers are better than him.

  • Rob

    I went with Ray but Pepe is close behind and he is still young with records of his own and I believe will get even better than the top goalkeeper he already is. I agree with a comment above if Pepe is still with the team in 5 years time then there is no contest to who is the greatest Liverpool keeper. YNWA

  • karl graham

    all greats in there own time, but give me the team’s between 70’s and 80’s any day of the week

  • Quincy

    I wanted to say Jerzy Dudek, but whatever, Jose Reina is also very good! =D

  • paul callery

    look at the equipment they have now clemo could save a ball without gloves

    LFC 4 LIFE
    CALLO.IRELAND.CO.DUBLIN

    • Red Knight

      Please read the history of Elisha Scott …Belfast Celtic Manager 1934-49 Liverpool Goalkeeper 1912-34 plus other info..a relative YNWA !!! R.I.P. Lish !!!

  • John K

    1) Ray clemence
    2) Jerzy Dudek
    3) Pepe Reina
    4) Bruce Grobbelaar
    5) David James

    In my books anyway LFC 4 Ever

  • joemack

    has to be Ray Clemence, completely dominated the area like no other goalie, anticipation was second to none and his general awareness has yet to be bettered. Pepe Reina is too hesistant to leave his line, has a tendency to flap at the ball, and lacks the confidence that stamped Clemence as one of the best.

  • yoven

    Reina remains for sure in all Liverpool fans heart and it seem to me that many has forgotten about Dudek,who we should not forget was the hero of the biggest ever champions league final,long live Liverpool……..you’ll never walk alone!!!!!!!!!

  • maxpinay

    Pepe Reina is the best, he’s still young and has many more years ahead of him… Cheers!

  • Red2707

    Reina without dad, sad he’ll go to spain in January though.

  • ROB1892

    My dad always used to say that Grobb used to clown around to much and made hard work of the easy stuff for him to be considered a great so used to go with Clemence. Having seen highlights and replays only of Clemence and Grobbalar i would have to agree that Ray was the better keeper, but over all it has to fall to Pepe for me because like above the defense has to be taken in to consideration also and our defense is no match for the one that would grace the pitch in Clemence’s day .

  • LFC EuroRed

    Supported the lads since ’62 and seen three of them in action.

    Pepe.

    In 10 years time there will be no vote on it.

  • Steve Burrows-Pym

    For me its Clem that has the edge (at the moment) his stats speak for themselves 6 missed league games in 11 yrs !,a bucket load of medals to boot. 16 goals conceded in a league season ( a record!).
    Reserve goalkeepers never got a look-in back then, now they play in the Carling cup to gain 1st team experience !
    Reina’s not far behind though and his penalty saving antics can only stand him in good stead, the future can only get better for Pepe so he could well take the premier spot if he remains loyal to Liverpool.

  • Shane Barry

    Great article guys, keep them coming. For me the greatest is Ray Clemence, but that’s based on us having a whole trophy-laden career to look back on. Reina has plenty of years ahead between the sticks and if he goes on to claim a few medals in the future, there may well be no debating who was the greatest.

  • VICTOR

    Reina is the best GoalKeeper at Liverpool. he can do better in future…

    • Kizy

      I do agree for sure Pepe is the best so far and can break all records and set new ones as he is already doing. YNWA Pepe hope u stay with us u a a legend.

  • Alastair Williams

    Im afraid this will be tarnished since people will not have seen some of the greats….. but for me, Ray Clemence’ stats speak for themselves, ultra-consistent in his time and his bravery in his attempt to get the ball was second to none. It is, in my opinion that the great era of the 70s in Liverpool’s history and be largely attributed to this man monster between the sticks.

  • Pete C

    completely agree with the above statement

    • Red Knight

      yes and what age about are you ???? no harm hun…did you ever see Elisha Scott Save Goals..did you know he was in the Championship League 1922 plus 1923 …of course you’re far too young though or never born..no harm meant by that remark..read your history 22yrs with LFC..Loyalty Counts you know !!! sorry all the history stuff on all the web sites is wrong per usual…awful they don’t even know Elisha’s true date of birth..I’ve his birth certificate 100% A Relative

  • Mark Jones

    Pepe Reina is the best keeper I’ve seen. I’d argue that the likes of Clemo and Brucie had far better defences in front of them.

    Reina saves pens without needing to do the wobbly legs and I reckon he is our greatest shot-stopper.